The Hidden Cost of Waiting: Why Succession Planning Should Start Years Before You Retire

Business Brokering Wednesday 6th of August 2025

Most practice owners don’t plan to leave their firm tomorrow. But waiting too long to start planning for succession? That’s where the trouble begins.

When you’ve spent years - decades, even - building a successful accounting or financial planning firm, it’s easy to fall into the trap of thinking you’ll just know when it’s time to pass the baton. After all, you’ve built a thriving business, loyal client relationships, and a team that runs like clockwork. Why rock the boat now?

The reality is that succession isn’t a single decision — it’s a process. And if you leave it too late, you risk undermining the very legacy you’ve worked so hard to build. Succession planning is not just about exit.

It’s about control.

There’s a big difference between being ready to retire and having a succession plan in place. A strong succession plan allows you to:

  • Choose the right successor or buyer (rather than being backed into a corner)
  • Maximise your valuation while your firm is still at its peak
  • Gradually reduce your involvement on your terms
  • Protect your staff, clients and culture through a smooth handover
  • Maintain flexibility in case life throws up surprises

Without a plan, you’re at the mercy of timing - and the market.

What waiting too long actually costs you

Here’s what we see time and again with firms that delay succession planning:

  • Diminishing valuation: A slow decline in energy, innovation, or responsiveness often results in flat or falling profitability. Buyers notice.
  • Limited buyer pool: Many top-tier buyers — especially younger equity partners or progressive firms — want a longer lead time for onboarding and succession. If you’re out in 3 months, they’re out.
  • Staff instability: Your team starts to sense uncertainty, and key talent may look elsewhere.
  • Stressful exits: Forced sales, rushed transitions, or last-minute restructures rarely go well. They’re disruptive, emotionally taxing, and value-destroying.

A better way: The Succession Runway

In our experience, the sweet spot for planning and executing a successful exit or equity transition is between 18 months and 3 years. Here’s why:

  • It typically takes 4 to 6 months to prepare, market and sell a firm, particularly if you want to attract a premium buyer, not just the first one to knock.
  • Following the sale most principals transition over 9 to 12 months, often in a reduced capacity, to maintain client and team continuity.
  • This means you need at least 18 months (or longer, ideally) to execute a proper succession to maximise options, valuation and cultural fit.

With that runway, you can stabilise earnings, prepare your team, and explore the right buyer or equity partner without pressure. It’s about staying in control, not scrambling in response.

Case in point: Two similar firms, two very different outcomes

Case A: A $1.2M suburban accounting practice reached out to us three years before the founder wanted to step back. We helped them explore both internal succession and external equity options, eventually securing a strategic merger with a like-minded firm that allowed the founder to reduce to 2 days a week within 18 months - while maintaining equity and income.

Case B: Another practice, similar in size and location, contacted us after the principal had already suffered a health scare and wanted out within 60 days. The result? A fire-sale environment with fewer interested buyers, less leverage in negotiations, and significant downward pressure on valuation.

A Final Thought

Succession isn’t just a technical process — it’s an emotional one. Succession can be confronting. Your firm may feel like an extension of your identity. Letting go, even partially, stirs up all sorts of emotions - uncertainty, pride, even grief.

That’s precisely why planning early is so critical. It gives you space to approach the process thoughtfully, not reactively.

Start while you’re strong. The best time to plan your succession is when things are going well - not when your energy, your health, or the market is on the decline. Start now, and you’ll give yourself the ultimate luxury: choice.

Want to explore what a well-timed succession plan could look like for your firm? Ready to take control of your succession plan? If you're starting to think about succession - even if you're years away from retiring - now is the time to start the conversation.

 

At Practice Exchange we specialise in helping firm owners structure deals that work not just on paper, but in practice. Whether you're looking to step back gradually, explore equity partner options, or prepare for a full exit, we can help you map out a clear, confident path forward.

Schedule a confidential call with Mark Witt CA via Calendly

Call 1300 722 452

Email mark@practiceexchange.com.au

Or browse our latest Practice Exchange listings

Don’t leave it too late. Start the conversation while you’re still in control.

Mark Witt CA

Mark is the Head of Brokering at Business Exchange with over 20 years experience and 400+ completed transactions


Read more articles

Partnership Pathways for Accountants & Financial Planners: Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne & Newcastle

For many accountants and financial planners in their thirties and forties, the conversation about partnership is no longer hypothetical. You’ve invested more than a decade building your expertise, nurturing client relationships, and leading teams. The technical ability is proven; the reputation established. Now the question shifts from “Can I do this?” to “What’s next, and how do I turn all this effort into real ownership and long-term wealth?”

Read More
Public or Private Marketplace: Which is Best for You?

When the time comes to sell or merge one of the first questions is: What’s the right pathway? For some firms, a public marketplace is the best way to generate momentum and competition. For others — particularly large regional practices or city firms — discretion is essential, and a private marketplace offers the safer, more effective option. At Practice Exchange, we facilitate both. With over 5,000 registered accountants and financial planners on our platform, we can create reach through our open marketplace while also offering a carefully managed, invitation-only process via our Private Broker Network™.

Read More
Is Now the Right Time to Sell Your Firm? Key Market Signals Every Owner Should Know

If you’re wondering whether now’s the right time to sell your accounting or financial planning firm, you’re not alone. It’s one of the most common - and emotionally loaded - questions firm owners wrestle with.

Read More
Bank Lending Policies Are Shaping the Way Equity Changes Hands in Accounting Firms

In today’s accounting practice acquisition market, the pathway to ownership is increasingly shaped not only by valuation or deal terms but by access to finance — and specifically, how banks are assessing risk in these transactions.

Read More
Exploring Mergers and Sell-Down Strategies: Strategic Pathways for Growth and Pre-Retirement

Navigating the evolving landscape of the accounting and financial planning industry requires strategic foresight and decisive action. Mergers and structured sell-down strategies have emerged as powerful tools to drive significant growth, enhance service offerings, secure capital for retiring professionals, and ensure a sustainable future for your firm.

Read More
Unlocking Growth: Lending Insights for Accounting and Financial Planning Firms

Unlock the potential of your accounting or financial planning firm with expert insights into bank credit policies. Discover how to leverage your firm’s goodwill to secure the financing you need for sustainable growth.

Read More
The Role of Equity Participation in Retaining Talent and Productivity

Equity participation - whether through full partnership or employee share schemes - emerges as a crucial strategy for "locking in" key team members and adding deeper meaning to their professional endeavours.

Read More
The Strategic Advantage of Off-Market Mergers for Small Practices

For small practices, off-market opportunities – strategic mergers with larger firms - offer a pathway not just to expansion but to a redefinition of what small practices can achieve when they leverage the right partnerships.

Read More
Pragmatic Strategies for Successful Client Transition in Accounting and Planning Practices

These strategies aim to preserve the relationships you've meticulously built and seek to enhance the practice's growth and continuity post-transition. The focus: keep the client's best interest at heart.

Read More
Exploring Flexible Succession Strategies in the Accounting and Planning Marketplaces

In today's dynamic accounting marketplace, vendors contemplating retirement or looking to scale down their involvement face a landscape rich with opportunities.

Read More
The Business Exchange Network - Transforming Business Brokering

The sun is fast setting on the old way of business brokering. The privileged position of a business broker as a gatekeeper to information and connection is under threat in a world where clients can now find each other via searches on smartphones, LinkedIn etc., and that means the most fundamental adage of business survival applies: adapt, or die.

Read More
About Business Exchange's Private Broker Network™ (PBN)

The Private Broker Network™ (PBN) is a members-only walled garden marketplace for business brokering and succession transactions. It is intended to be used by large networks of member businesses such as financial planning dealer groups and franchises.

Read More
The Importance of Allocating Time for Navigating Client Relationships Post-Sale

Client relationships within an accounting practice portfolio are anchored on mutual respect, trust and understanding. They can take a professional lifetime to build. As you near retirement, the onus is on you to ensure a smooth transfer of these relationships to guarantee continued success for the practice.

Read More
Timing is Everything: Guarding Your Practice's Value at Retirement

Retirement, while a celebratory milestone, presents unique challenges for accountants. Successful transition demands a precise strategy to secure the value built up over a lifetime of professional practice.

Read More
Partnerships in the New Era: Navigating the Future with Toffler's Timeless Insights

Beneath the warm glow of a Zoom call, two business partners lock eyes, or rather cursors, and prepare for a brave new world. Their partnership, formed during the great pandemic, has been forged in the crucible of COVID-19. Now, as they brace for an AI-enabled future, they turn to the prophetic wisdom of futurist Alvin Toffler for guidance.

Read More
Expanding Horizons: How Joining an Accounting Partnership Can Transform Your Sole Practice

As an accountant, you've likely experienced the challenges of managing a sole practice, from juggling multiple clients to staying on top of industry trends. Merging with an established accounting partnership can allow you to streamline your operations, expand your client base and boost your professional growth.

Read More
Press Release: Business Exchange: A Game-Changer in the Accounting M&A Landscape

Leveraging industry expertise, unmatched buyer access, and cutting-edge technology to redefine the M&A marketplace

Read More
Choosing Your Legacy - Thoughts on the Empty Chair

Some practitioners are comfortable with the assumption that they will continue working until the end of their life, what might be considered the 'die at your desk' model. Fair enough, but there are big problems if you arrive at this position by default.

Read More
Merging to Retire - Is this an Option for You?

Succession can take many forms depending on your situation and goals. Considering a merger can give you options beyond a simple all-or-nothing sale.

Read More